Confidentiality




Sample Paper Excerpt
The reviewer has completed a review within the prescribed time frame and sent the review response form back to the editor. It contained comments intended for the editor, including a recommendation to accept with minor revisions, and helpful suggestions that the authors of the manuscript might incorporate to improve the paper. This reviewer, who shares an office with another researcher, has left the manuscript with the accompanying comments, in a common area that is used by both researchers. The document remains in the area for a two week period during which time his officemate happens to peruse the manuscript.

Has the reviewer acted responsibly?
No, this represents a violation of confidentiality. Yes, since the reviewer has already submitted the review form with comments.

Proceed to the


Finished?